Skip to content
Submit
Close search
Submit
Search
Log in
Cart
Facebook
Instagram
Order
Order Menu
Order
Pie Crust Orders
Pickup Sweet Pea's Mayville
Door Dash Delivery Mayville
Thanksgiving Mayville Pre-order
Shipping Only
Local Markets
Sell Our Pies
Fundraising
About
Contact
Baking Instructions
Order
Pie Crust Orders
Pickup Sweet Pea's Mayville
Door Dash Delivery Mayville
Thanksgiving Mayville Pre-order
Shipping Only
Local Markets
Sell Our Pies
Fundraising
About
Contact
Baking Instructions
Collection:
Thanksgiving Preorder
Filter by
All products
48 hours
Available
banana cream
cake pop
Cakes
chocolate
christmas
cookie
Cookies
cream pie
french silk
gluten-free
key lime
Pies
pistachio
sugar-free
Sweet Pea Pickup
vegan
Sort by
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
31 products
10" Pie Crust | Mayville Pick-up
10" Pie Crust | Mayville Pick-up
Regular price
$4.99
Sale price
$4.99
Sale
9x13 Egg and French Toast Bakes | Mayville pick-up
9x13 Egg and French Toast Bakes | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$18.00
Sale price
$18.00
Sale
Banana Cream Pie | 9 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Banana Cream Pie | 9 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$20.99
Sale price
$20.99
Sale
Berrylicious Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Berrylicious Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$14.99
Sale price
$14.99
Sale
Blueberry Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Blueberry Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$14.99
Sale price
$14.99
Sale
Bundt Cake - Mayville pick-up
Bundt Cake - Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$26.99
Sale price
$26.99
Sale
Cake Pop | Mayville Pick-up
Cake Pop | Mayville Pick-up
Regular price
$2.50
Sale price
$2.50
Sale
Caramel Apple Crumble Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Caramel Apple Crumble Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$14.99
Sale price
$14.99
Sale
Cheesecake | Baked -8 Inch | Mayville Pick-up
Cheesecake | Baked -8 Inch | Mayville Pick-up
Regular price
$32.00
Sale price
$32.00
Sale
Coconut Cream Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Coconut Cream Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$20.99
Sale price
$20.99
Sale
Cookie Dough | Frozen - 2 pounds | Mayville pick-up
Cookie Dough | Frozen - 2 pounds | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$9.95
Sale price
$9.95
Sale
Cranberry Custard Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Cranberry Custard Pie | 10 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$15.99
Sale price
$15.99
Sale
French Silk Pie | 9 Inch | Mayville pick-up
French Silk Pie | 9 Inch | Mayville pick-up
Regular price
$23.99
Sale price
$23.99
Sale
Gluten-Free Pie | 10 Inch - Baked | Mayville Pick-Up
Gluten-Free Pie | 10 Inch - Baked | Mayville Pick-Up
Regular price
$21.99
Sale price
$21.99
Sale
Gluten-Free Pie | 10 Inch - U Bake | Mayville Pick-Up
Gluten-Free Pie | 10 Inch - U Bake | Mayville Pick-Up
Regular price
$16.99
Sale price
$16.99
Sale
Gourmet Apple Pie (dinner bell) - 10 Inch | Mayville PIck-Up
Gourmet Apple Pie (dinner bell) - 10 Inch | Mayville PIck-Up
Regular price
$30.99
Sale price
$30.99
Sale
Previous page
Page 1 of 2
Next page
choosing a selection results in a full page refresh
