Sweet Pea - that's me!

I grew up making pies and cookies with my grandmas.  Grandma Matthews gave me the nickname, "Sweet Pea", while Grandma Peterson gave me her rhubarb custard recipe.  My baby book tells the story, "loves cake".  I guess I was born with a thing for sweets that are worth the calories and that's never changed.

Now we make All American pie from scratch in our Mayville, Wisconsin, kitchen.  You can visit our retail store, ship our pies within the USA, find us at markets in Wisconsin and Minnesota, or sell our pies as a fundraiser to support local causes.

After closing Glorious Beans, our coffee shop cafe in the Outlets in Albertville, I decided to bring a pie to our local meat market to see if they would sell them.  Fast forward all these years and pies are still our thing.

Here's what makes our treats seriously craveable:

Licensed & insured - got it

Customer satisfaction - check

Treats that are worth the calories - yep

Heirloom and original recipes - of course

Small batch from scratch baking - we do that

Support local non-profit with every purchase - absolutely

 

Here are the highlights of our delicious journey:

2009 We sell our first pie in Elk River Minnesota at Elk River Meats

October 2020 we buy a building in Mayville, WI, for our new retail location

October 2020 Anoka Meat and Sausage and Center Cut Meats in Rogers starts selling our pie

November 2020 we deliver our first pies to Horicon, WI

February 2021 we are in the top five contestants for a $10,000 makeover

April 2021 Ralphie's Minnoco in Elk River starts to sell our pie

April 2021 Mayville is awarded a CDI Grant by the WEDC to help renovate our historic building

April 2021 we move to Mayville permanently and begin renovations.  

May 2021 The Elk River Meat Market closes, but we continue to make pies in Minnesota during our Wisconsin renovations

July 2021 we are licensed to make pies in Wisconsin. Our manufacturing facility moves to WI, but we continue to deliver pies to Minnesota

September 17th - opened our retail location in Mayville, WI and start selling Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream alongside our all american pie and scratch-made treats

October 14th - Grand Opening Celebration

November 2021 - our first Thanksgiving in Mayville and a visit from Brian Kramp

Part of WEDC 2021 Making Strong Connections report

Featured SBDC Client Success Story

Featured Food Finance Institute Edible Alpha Podcast

Featured as Kiva Funded through WWBIC

September 2022 - Bring Door Dash to Mayville

April 2024 accepted on the WBA board and awarded RISING STAR of the year

April 2024 - wedding pie featured in Premier Bride magazine

July 2024 - Mayville Piggly Wiggly and three other Piggly Wiggly grocery stores stock take and bake pies in their freezers

We think pie builds community and makes the world a better place.  The world could use more smiles, so we'll keep making pie.

"I've never seen someone eating pie that didn't smile!"