Skip to content

Order Valentine's

Stay at our AirBnB

Valentine's Pre-Order
Ship Pie
Shop Main Street
- Mayville Pick-Up
  
  Same Day Pick-Up
  48 hr notice: Pie, Cake, Cheesecake, Cookies & more
  Valentine's Pre-Order
- Free-From Treats
  
  Gluten-Free Friendly Treats
  Sugar-Free Pie
  Vegan Pies
- Door Dash Delivery
- Find Pie at WI & MN Retailers
Sell and Fundraise
- Wholesale Pies
- Fundraising
Stay on Main Street
- 1 Bedroom Vintage Chic
- 2 Bedroom HIstoric Charm
About Us
- Press
- Contact
Earn Points: Get Rewards
Pie Instructions
News
Sitemap

Facebook
Instagram

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Home› Advance Order for Pick-Up

Collection: Advance Order for Pick-Up

Filter:

Category

0 selected

Category

Bakery (44 products)
Cakes (4 products)
Cakes & Dessert Bars (6 products)
Cookies (4 products)
Event Tickets (1 product)
Pie Crusts (1 product)
Pies & Tarts (32 products)

46 products

Filter Filter

Filter

Filter

46 products

Category

Bakery (44 products)
Cakes (4 products)
Cakes & Dessert Bars (6 products)
Cookies (4 products)
Event Tickets (1 products)
Pie Crusts (1 products)
Pies & Tarts (32 products)

Clear

Remove all

46 products

Valentine’s Lux Pie Flight: Chocolate & Raspberry (5” Mini Pies)

Valentine’s Lux Pie Flight: Chocolate & Raspberry (5” Mini Pies)

Regular price $34.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $34.00 USD
Strawberry Chantilly Cake

Strawberry Chantilly Cake

Regular price From $36.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $36.00 USD
Cheesecake

Cheesecake

Regular price From $32.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $32.00 USD
Build Your Own Cake

Build Your Own Cake

Regular price $0.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $0.00 USD
Sweet Pea’s 5-Inch Baked Pie Sampler 4-Pack

Sweet Pea’s 5-Inch Baked Pie Sampler 4-Pack

Regular price From $28.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $28.00 USD
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (Vegan)

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie (Vegan)

Regular price From $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $16.00 USD
Gourmet Apple Pie (dinner bell)

Gourmet Apple Pie (dinner bell)

Regular price $30.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $30.99 USD
Gourmet Cherry Pie (prairie star)

Gourmet Cherry Pie (prairie star)

Regular price $34.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $34.99 USD
Pie Crust

Pie Crust

Regular price From $4.99 USD

Regular price Sale price From $4.99 USD
Berrylicious Pie (Vegan)

Berrylicious Pie (Vegan)

Regular price From $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $16.00 USD
Blueberry Pie (Vegan)

Blueberry Pie (Vegan)

Regular price From $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $16.00 USD
Apple Pie (Vegan)

Apple Pie (Vegan)

Regular price From $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $16.00 USD

1
2
3
4

Pie Baking Instructions

Do not thaw before baking. For full instructions click here.

Mayville Air BnB Rentals

2 Bedroom Historic Charm
1 Bedroom Vintage Chic

Brick and Mortar Store

4 S Main Street | Mayville WI 53050

920.644.2293

Subscribe to our emails

Email

Facebook
Instagram

Payment methods

© 2026, Sweet Pea's Powered by Shopify

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy
Contact information

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.