Skip to content

Order Valentine's

Stay at our AirBnB

Valentine's Pre-Order
Ship Pie
Shop Main Street
- Mayville Pick-Up
  
  Same Day Pick-Up
  48 hr notice: Pie, Cake, Cheesecake, Cookies & more
  Valentine's Pre-Order
- Free-From Treats
  
  Gluten-Free Friendly Treats
  Sugar-Free Pie
  Vegan Pies
- Door Dash Delivery
- Find Pie at WI & MN Retailers
Sell and Fundraise
- Wholesale Pies
- Fundraising
Stay on Main Street
- 1 Bedroom Vintage Chic
- 2 Bedroom HIstoric Charm
About Us
- Press
- Contact
Earn Points: Get Rewards
Pie Instructions
News
Sitemap

Facebook
Instagram

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Home› Sweet Pea's In Store Pickup

Collection: Sweet Pea's In Store Pickup

Filter:

Category

0 selected

Category

Bakery (54 products)
Berries (1 product)
Beverages (10 products)
Cakes (8 products)
Cakes & Dessert Bars (13 products)
Chocolate (1 product)
Cookies (4 products)
Dog Treats (1 product)
Dough (3 products)
Event Tickets (1 product)
Frosting & Icing (1 product)
Ice Cream (2 products)
Ice Cream Novelties (1 product)
Juices, Milkshakes & Smoothies (4 products)
Magazines & Newspapers (1 product)
Pie Crusts (1 product)
Pies & Tarts (32 products)
Prepared Meals & Entrées (3 products)
Soda (3 products)
Water (1 product)

89 products

Filter Filter

Filter

Filter

89 products

Category

Bakery (54 products)
Berries (1 products)
Beverages (10 products)
Cakes (8 products)
Cakes & Dessert Bars (13 products)
Chocolate (1 products)
Cookies (4 products)
Dog Treats (1 products)
Dough (3 products)
Event Tickets (1 products)
Frosting & Icing (1 products)
Ice Cream (2 products)
Ice Cream Novelties (1 products)
Juices, Milkshakes & Smoothies (4 products)
Magazines & Newspapers (1 products)
Pie Crusts (1 products)
Pies & Tarts (32 products)
Prepared Meals & Entrées (3 products)
Soda (3 products)
Water (1 products)

Clear

Remove all

89 products

Smore's Pie

Smore's Pie

Regular price From $20.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $20.00 USD
Sweet Pea’s 5-Inch Baked Pie Sampler 4-Pack

Sweet Pea’s 5-Inch Baked Pie Sampler 4-Pack

Regular price From $28.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $28.00 USD
Cheesecake

Cheesecake

Regular price From $32.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $32.00 USD
Cranberry Custard Pie

Cranberry Custard Pie

Regular price From $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $18.00 USD
Rhubarb Custard Pie

Rhubarb Custard Pie

Regular price From $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $18.00 USD
Lemon Ice Box Pie

Lemon Ice Box Pie

Regular price From $22.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $22.00 USD
Bluebarb Pie (Vegan)

Bluebarb Pie (Vegan)

Regular price From $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $16.00 USD
Caramel Cashew Bar

Caramel Cashew Bar

Regular price From $6.95 USD

Regular price Sale price From $6.95 USD
Cake Type - 10

Cake Type - 10

Regular price From $0.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $0.00 USD
Cake Type - 8

Cake Type - 8

Regular price From $0.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $0.00 USD
Decoration Preference- 6 Traditional

Decoration Preference- 6 Traditional

Regular price From $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $15.00 USD
Ice Cream Cake 8"

Ice Cream Cake 8"

Regular price From $38.50 USD

Regular price Sale price From $38.50 USD

1
2
3
4
5
6
…
8

Pie Baking Instructions

Do not thaw before baking. For full instructions click here.

Mayville Air BnB Rentals

2 Bedroom Historic Charm
1 Bedroom Vintage Chic

Brick and Mortar Store

4 S Main Street | Mayville WI 53050

920.644.2293

Subscribe to our emails

Email

Facebook
Instagram

Payment methods

© 2026, Sweet Pea's Powered by Shopify

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy
Contact information

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.